The FFRF Action Fund is lauding a victory this month for the rights of terminally ill patients in two more states.
With Gov. Kathy Hochul’s signing of Senate Bill 138 on Dec. 17 and Gov. J.B. Pritzker’s signing of Senate Bill 1950 on Dec. 12, New York and Illinois join 11 other forward-thinking states in adopting medical-aid-in-dying (MAID) laws.
The new laws permit adults with a terminal prognosis and confirmed decision-making capacity to request medication from their physicians and to choose whether and when to end their life peacefully, rather than enduring months of prolonged suffering.
Religious groups, especially the Roman Catholic hierarchy, are in the forefront of opposing these bills, arguing that they constitute “playing God” and suggesting that individuals should endure their final months in suffering so their families can witness a “natural death.”
After refusing to sign previous legislation, when Hochul signed Senate Bill 183, she invoked the experience of her mother, who died of ALS. Hochul’s press release lists the many guardrails. Illinois’ governor signed into law the End-of-Life Options for Terminally Ill Patients Act (SB 1950). Under this law, which takes effect next September, qualified terminally ill patients — defined as adults with a prognosis of six months or less to live who are capable of making their own health decisions — may request and obtain medication from their physician to end their lives on their own terms. The law allocates time for the Illinois Department of Public Health and health care providers to develop protocols and protections, including eligibility assessments and waiting periods, before implementation.
By joining other states with similar MAID legislation, New York and Illinois affirm that individuals and their physicians should make deeply personal decisions about dying. This legislation rejects government-imposed religious or ideological doctrines while implementing stringent safeguards to prevent coercion and protect vulnerable individuals. Ultimately, these laws honor the constitutional principle of separating religion and government, and prioritize evidence-based, humane terminal care options that honor individual freedom of conscience.
“Passage of medical aid-in-dying legislation in New York and Illinois is a powerful affirmation that personal autonomy and compassion must prevail over religious dogma,” says Action Fund President Annie Laurie Gaylor. “These laws respect the right of terminally ill patients to make deeply personal medical decisions based on their own values, in consultation with their physicians and loved ones.”
New York and Illinois join California, Colorado, Delaware, Hawaii, Maine, Montana, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Vermont and Washington, plus the District of Columbia, in permitting medical aid-in-dying.
FFRF Action Fund remains dedicated to ensuring every terminally ill individual retains the right to choose their own path and will continue advocating for compassionate, patient-centered end-of-life options in every state.